Showing posts with label Reasoning and Proof. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Reasoning and Proof. Show all posts

November 15, 2010

Proofs and Counterexamples about Continuous Functions

This study focused on reasoning and proof from undergraduate math majors in calculus. Proofs of truths and counterexamples of false facts have been shown to help students understand them. Not only do they help explain why a statement is true or false, but students will also be able to see how. However, reading proofs and constructing them are different processes. In my personal experience, constructing proofs is very difficult especially when I don't know what direction in which I need to head.

Before constructing proofs/counterexamples, students and teachers need to decide which one to produce (to prove a truth or to disprove a falsity?), which means they must decide on the validity of the proposition (is it true or false?), which means they must have a deep understanding of the concepts involved. In fact, many students and teachers have difficulty deciding whether a proposition is true or false because of their inadequate understanding of the mathematical content. Still, many mathematicians often struggle with formal proofs. Thus more effective ways of teaching these are needed, at least in the undergraduate math major domain.

Ko and Knuth (2009, p. 69) pose two research questions for this study:

  1. How well do undergraduates construct proofs and generate counterexamples in the domain of continuous functions?
  2. What problems appear in the proofs students construct or the counterexamples they generate?

One thing that the authors stated that I found striking was the fact that proof serves as a means of communication among mathematicians. This makes sense, because I noticed when learners can explain something in each others' terms, they gain a better understanding of the idea. Informally, they are proving it to one another.

We usually think of counterexamples, as disputes to generalizing statements. For example, the number $2$ would be a counterexample (in fact, the only one) to the false proposition, All prime numbers are odd. Some counterexamples can actually be ‘examples’, if we think of them as a proof to the generalizing statement's negation (e.g., $2$ is an example that proves the conjecture, There exists an even prime number).

The authors also discussed different types of proof schemes and counterexamples and the properties of each. They created a scale or spectrum of proofs, and one for counterexamples, that ranged by robustness. After receiving calculus students' work on a problem set, they rated it using their own spectra.

Since constructing a proof requires sufficient background knowledge and the decision of whether to prove or disprove, Ko and Knuth (2009) suggest that math teachers should provide a learning environment in which students can easily decide the veracity of statements. There are several methods of doing this. Especially in secondary school, formal proof is not even in the question. Therefore teachers must foster students' informal proof and reasoning as often as possible. Fishbein (1982) states, Ignoring students' intuitive representations of proof does not promote their mathematical understanding (as cited in Ko and Knuth, 2009, p. 75). In addition to drawing attention to students' intuitive thinking, teachers should also explicitly identify students' logical flaws and misconceptions so that they will have a stronger understanding of the processes in constructing (even informal) proofs.

References

  • Ko, Y., & Knuth, E. (). Undergraduate mathematics majors' writing performance producing proofs and counterexamples about continuous functions. Journal of Mathematical Behavior, 28, 68–77.

January 22, 2009

Why Two Wrongs Make a Right

Rapke (2008) explores the reasons why $(-1)(-1)=1$ and what knowledge must be known to explain it. I liked how she divided her findings into two sections: Pseduoreasoning, and formal explanations. In order to rigorously prove $(-1)(-1)=1$, background information on the distributive property and other axioms (but not really) of the real numbers is required.

The point Rapke makes is that when teaching children mathematical axioms, they must be taught why. Teaching a student the reason why a property holds will help them build skills as recognizing patterns. If we say, believe for now then the student will just accept the fact without question, and will only regurgitate that information on a test.

There were many different approaches to the explanation of why $(-1)(-1)=1$, including word problems, but Rapke says that these word problems are inaccurate and may be falsely logical. It cannot help the student identify a similar situation and use the same concept. Another method is that students may use patterns to predict solutions. Although this is not a formal proof, it can provide for some great intuitive reasoning and even lead to inductive reasoning. I never realized, however, that it is not ideal because because sometimes the pattern may not work. For example, when trying to find $0^0$, the student may write this:

$$
(-2)^0=1\\
(-1)^0=1\\
0^0=?\\
1^0=1\\
2^0=1\\
\therefore 0^0=1
$$

In other words, $\lim_{x\to 0} x^{0} = 1$. Following this pattern, students were led to believe that $0^{0}=1$. Since $0^0 \neq 1$, the patten fails. Sometimes using patterns does not lead to correct results, regardless of the intuitive benefits they provide.

In addition, students may develop a pattern for the wrong reason when trying to solve a problem. Using patterns to explain concepts is not ideal because teachers must explain which patterns are okay to use, which are not, and which have exceptions.

Rapke says that the most ideal method of proving the $(-1)(-1)=1$ problem is to use the distributive property. Furthermore, all algebraic properties should be used, because all algebraic properties hold across the number systems real numbers, which is the number system used in 99% of high school mathematics.

References

  • Rapke, T. (). Thoughts on why (-1)(-1)=+1. Mathematics Teacher, 102(5), 374–376.